I was upset to be unable to join the recent debate in New York on digital banking. It ended up that I was conflicted and had to defer to a far mightier second man, Ron Shevlin. Ron obviously was a standout star of the discussion in that not only did he win the debate with Michal Panowicz as his tag team partner, he also got a lot of coverage of his rap …
Don’t be a fool,
fintech don’t rule.
No doubt they’re cool.
But they’re just a bank’s tool.
Two standout articles have appeared subsequent to the debate, from Sarah Todd in American Banker, and Sam Maule in Bank Innovation. Sam’s article in particular resonated as it focused on Paul Revere’s Midnight Ride alerting the rebellious colonials to the fact that the Brits were coming. Ron Shevlin likened this to Jamie Dimon’s comments that fintech is coming, and we know how this ended (the Brits lost, as will fintech in Ron’s view).
Sam calls Ron on this one, though, and says that although the American rebels beat the British in 1776, it all ended up in a ‘special relationship’, and that’s what will happen with banks and fintech. I somewhat agree, and would rather liken the Brits to the banks, and the rebels to the startups. The startups may win the battle, but there won’t be a war – just a symbiotic special relationship. As Sam says: “Over time, the US and Britain became strong allies and developed what is known as the special relationship. I believe that the banking ecosystem will thrive with growing the special relationship between banks and fintech.”
This is where it gets interesting, as I mentioned this to a bank friend last night and he responded by saying that there already is a special relationship out there. Many banks are investing in and mentoring startups, helping them to flourish and grow. Many banks are engaged in the blockchain and cryptocurrencies. Many banks are offering joint ventures with crowdfunders, or investing in P2P lenders. Santander recently announced over 20 use cases for the blockchain in banking, Barclays is nurturing blockchain startups, while UBS has opened a London-based blockchain research lab.
On the P2P lending side, according to the Financial Times, the US P2P lending ‘platforms have been dominated by institutional money, since both Prosper and Lending Club shut their doors in 2008 – under pressure from regulators that did not want them to offer securities to all and sundry – and relaunched in a different guise. About 80% of their loans are taken by institutions, and they have dropped the ‘peer-to-peer’ label.’
In the UK, Santander and RBS have partnered with Funding Circle to say that if your credit history, as a small business, isn’t good enough to get a loan with them, then talk to Funding Circle. Equally, Goldman Sachs and Société Générale are rumored to be backing Aztec Money, an emerging peer-to-peer financing platform where people can bid for company invoices. In fact, I see more and more of these partnerships developing every day.
Narrow finance focuses on a piece of the financial system and democratizes it, or if you prefer, connects that system by replacing the trusted third party institution with a trusted third party processor. Fintech focuses on replacing buildings with servers, and in so doing wipes out a ton of cost overhead. So, there’s nothing alternative about this. It’s core.
However, even if fintech does grow into a larger monster, there’s plenty of time for banks to respond by either acquiring or launching competitive services, such as Goldman Sachs’ P2P lender. Just to put it in perspective, these two Economist articles make the point.
Through crowdfunding, ‘websites, individuals and funds provided over €1.5bn ($2bn) in equity and debt to European small- and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) in 2014 … that is a pittance compared with the €926bn of total new external funding made available to European SMEs the year before, mostly by banks.’
The P2P lending ‘sector has grown rapidly: the five biggest platforms for consumer lending – Lending Club, Prosper and SoFi, all based in San Francisco, and Zopa and RateSetter in London – have so far issued nearly one million loans between them and are generating more at the rate of well over $10bn a year … those loans are still dwarfed by the $3tn of consumer debt outstanding in America alone.’
In other words, there’s a long way to go before fintech becomes mainstream, and it’s going to take a long time before the world really takes notice. By the time it does, most banks will own this sector or a large part of it, so don’t write off the banking system too soon.
As I would say to the fintech community, the banks are coming, and we all know how that turned out, don’t we?
– This article is reproduced with kind permission. Some minor changes have been made to reflect BankNXT style considerations. You can read the original article here.